2 SC justices won't inhibit in pleas vs CJ trial

Posted at 02/07/2012 4:25 PM | Updated as of 02/07/2012 4:25 PM

MANILA, Philippines - Supreme Court Associate Justices Antonio Carpio and Ma. Lourdes Sereno have denied motions for their inhibitions from deliberations on separate petitions filed asking the high tribunal to stop the impeachment trial of Chief Justice Renato Corona.

Court spokesman and Court Administrator Jose Midas Marquez said both justices denied the motions for "lack of merit."

"These motions have been denied. Motions for inhibitions are addressed to the individual justices," he said.

The motions were filed by lawyers Homobono Adaza and Alan Paguia who claimed both magistrates had "interests" in the outcome of the petitions.

Adaza and Paguia, who are among those who petitioned the high court to stop Corona's impeachment trial on grounds of unconstitutionality, alleged that Carpio and Sereno cannot be expected to be impartial since either of them may be appointed Chief Justice to replace Corona in the event he is convicted by the Senate impeachment court.

Both claimed Carpio and Sereno may be considered the frontrunners should Corona be ousted from office.

Carpio was Corona's staunch rival in the last race for chief magistrate. Sereno, meantime, is the first appointee to the high tribunal by President Aquino.

Motions for the inhibition of justices  in the high tribunal in particular cases are acted upon by the justices concerned.


Bookmark and Share

5 comments

ACCUSATION ACADEMIC AND MOOT

PARANG ITO NA ANG TRENDING NA WORDS SA PINAS" ACADEMIC AND MOOT" , 'BASELESS' AND 'LACK OF MERIt"..HA HA HA HA.. THAT'S WHAT I WOULD SAY IN THIS PETITION FILED BY THE ABOGAGONG MR Adaza and Paguia!!!! GIVE UP!!!


▼▼▼ LEAKED BANK DOCUMENTS ▼▼▼

Extreme loads of Money in bank accounts
that might even surpass
the wealth accumulated by Pacquiao

http://vwv pinakamagaling com/bank-acct-docu


kailangan ng boss nila ang

kailangan ng boss nila ang mga votes nila against cj... parang drilon lang yan sa impeachment trial eh pakapal muks nalang sila.lol


Ipinapakita dito ng dalawang

Ipinapakita dito ng dalawang Associate Justices Sereno and Carpio na hindi sila miyembro ng sindikato. Their decision was correct since the petition by Paguia and Adaza lacks merit and malicious.


HOMOPHOBIA

Mr. Adaza's perception that either of the two Justices may be appointed Chief Justice to replace Corona in the event he is convicted by the Senate impeachment court is biased and self-serving. The fact remains that any of the other Justices may also be appointed as replacement. This means that all 14 Justices should inhibit themselves from hearing the case.



Links