Journey's Arnel Pineda says sorry to NHI
MANILA, Philippines - Arnel Pineda, the Filipino frontman of rock band Journey, apologized Tuesday to the National Historical Institute (NHI) for singing the Philippine national anthem incorrectly during the March 13 bout between Pinoy boxing champ Manny Pacquiao and Ghanaian challenger Joshua Clottey.
"I apologize for my dissatisfactory performance dun sa fight ni Pacquiao and Clottey sa Dallas, Texas, according to their standards. What can I do? I'm just doing my job... but then again hindi ako sorry kasi artistic freedom ko yon. It doesn't make me less of a Filipino dahil sa nabago ang pagkakanta," Pineda said in an abs-cbnNEWS.com interview.
Pineda said that he really did his best to represent the country while singing the anthem. The NHI earlier said it is looking into the possibility of filing a complaint against him.
"Ano ba ang bago? 'Yong traditional na pagkanta ng 'Lupang Hinirang' ang gusto nilang marinig. On my part, I'm just doing my artistic freedom. I was there as Filipino representing Pacquiao and the Philippines. 'Yun ang importante," Pineda added.
On Monday, Teddy Atienza, chief of NHI’s Heraldry Section, told abs-cbnNEWS.com that the board was not pleased when it heard Pineda’s version of “Lupang Hinirang” during the Pacquiao-Clottey fight in the United States.
Atienza lamented that Pineda sang the anthem slowly instead of of its original march tempo. He also scored the singer for belting out the last 2 words of “Lupang Hinirang” and being out of tune.
He said this was a clear violation of Republic Act (RA) 8491. RA 8491 prescribes that any person who will violate its provisions may be punished by a fine of at least P20,000 or imprisonment of not more than one year.
Pineda, meanwhile, admitted that he went off-pitch near the end of the song because he could no longer hear himself sing.
"Alam ko naman na nag-flat ako kasi ang parte na yon na nagsimula ng magsigawan ang tao. Wala akong ear monitor. Hindi ko na marinig ang sarili ko noong pumapasok ako doon sa line na 'lupa ng araw ng luwalhati't pagsinta.' Sumisigaw na sila, highlight ng melody ng kanta 'yon sa unti-unti hindi ko naririnig," he said.
Aside from his performance, Pineda is also being criticized for wearing a cowboy-inspired polo instead of the traditional Barong Tagalog.
In the interview, the crooner cleared that what he wore during the Pacman-Clottey bout was a modern Barong Tagalog made by Filipino fashion designer Ariel Agasang.
"Barong 'yon. 'Yon ang modern barong gawa ni Filipino designer na si Ariel Agasang na siya ding gumawa ng damit para kay Piolo Pascual," he said.
Martin defends Arnel
Pineda was not the first singer to be reprimanded by the NHI for singing the anthem wrong. Other singers who have been reprimanded by the NHI are balladeer Jennifer Bautista, Christian Bautista, international singing sensation Charice and Concert King Martin Nievera.
In an interview with ABS-CBN's morning show "Umagang Kay Ganda," Nievera said Pineda performed very well during the Pacquiao-Clottey fight.
"Well unang-una ginawa niya yon from the heart. Obviously binago din ang ending. For me, I see nothing wrong with that dahil hindi naman ako kasama sa NHI. For me, I think Arnel did a very good job," he said.
Nievera also said that as a rocker, Pineda should be given some leeway if he went off-pitch during the song.
"Well siguro si Arnel pinili niya 'yong isang key na masyadong mataas ang umpisa. Pero feeling ko lang dahil siyempre lead singer ng Journey, rock and roll yan, ang mga rockers kasama sa boses nila 'yan na may konting basag o kanting paos o konting crack sa voice so parang poetic license yon para sa isang rock singer katulad ni Arnel," Nievera said.
Nievera also shared that singing live in front of thousands of screaming fans could cause any singer to hit some bad notes.
"Kasama din 'yon na may konting nerves at konting excitement din. Siyempre, maraming pride 'yon na tumatakbo sa utak at puso niya. May pride din. Kasama din yun sa 51,000 screaming fans," Nievera said.
While saying that Pineda had nothing to apologize for, Nievera did advise the Journey frontman to get a lawyer who will help him write a letter of apology to the NHI.
"Unang-una I know pretty much kung ano ang mangyayari ngayon. Hahanapan nila ng apology. Ssana hindi darating doon but he has to talk to some lawyers to help him write a nice letter of apology para walang sama ng loob for both sides," he said.
He added: "But personally if you will ask me I think Arnel has nothing to apologize for. He sang like a Journey singer, like a Filipino that we are proud to watch and I'm very proud of him."
For Pineda, he also agreed with Nievera that his performance was a reflection of his work as a rock singer.
"I did my best and I think that's good enough for me. Siyempre being brought up as a rock and roll singer, 'yun ang influence ko," he said. Reyma Buan-Deveza, abs-cbnNEWS.com
Pointless
Pointless just like MTCRB... mga tanga!!!
Si Guy at Pip ang pakantahin niyo ng Bayang MAgiliw
Sana magdueto ulit ang aking mga idolo na si Tirso Cruz at Nora Aunor at kantahin nila ang Bayang Magiliw. Kung hindi naman puede sila, sana magdueto ulit ang aking pangalawang paborito na si Edgar Mortiz at Vilma Santos, ikumpara natin kung sino ang mas magandang bumanat ng Bayang Magiliw
Pointless
Again, Arnel did not violate any law. Philippine laws apply only within Philippine national territory. Since Arnel sang the assailed version of the national anthem in Texas, USA, then the Philippine Flag Law cited by the NHI is inapplicable. It is pointless to discuss the issue of prosecution.
always like this
mga filipino singers maaarte . kanta na pilit pang kinakanta pati Lupang Hinirang binababoy , para mapag usapan lang. tapos sasabihin artist freedom. dapat sa mga yan ipakulong pag inulit. paulit ulit na lang nila ginagawa yan
Kuya Manny Pacman!
Kuya Manny, baka puede naman makahingi ng balato,,,,alam ko mahirap ang boxing pero sigurado another millions na naman sa susunod na laban mo,,,payag ako maski water boy mo o kahit na ano pa, kahit driver mo nalang,,,God bless us always.
nag-sorry pero binawi rin agad
nag sorry ka pa. ganun ba talaga ang rock and roll? basag na ang boses, off-key pa. baka gusto niyang buhayin yung mga legends of rock and roll na namatay na.
sa amerika ginawa yung pagkanta, pero hindi sakop ang amerika ng batas ng pilipinas, kaya paporma lang yang ingay ng NHI kasi hindi naman nila masamsampahan ng kaso ang sinumang singer na kakanta ng Lupang Hinirang nang hindi ayon sa orihinal na komposisyon.
Pacman #1
Dong congratulation!wala na akong masasabi pa,proud ako sa iyo pero isang hiling pa,pakidurog mo nga ang mukha ni Mayweather kasi sobrang yabang ng hinayupak na yun e,,,,ungoy kasi! please lang ha Dong,para matahimik na ang ungoy na iyon at pati narin lahi nila....sobra na silang manlait!
Learn from Broadway and Hollywood Movies Musicals
Learn from Broadway and Hollywood Movies Musicals. Don't just belt out high-pitched ear-piercing notes.
Atienza Tite mong may asen
Tila sumosobra naman yata tayo Parekoy!wala naba kayong magawa at pati kanta e pinaglilihihan na ninyo,sobrang dami ng problema ng bayan natin e yan pang kanta ni Arnel ang napagdiskitahan ninyo,he did his best at wala akong nakitang masama sa kanta niya,ang mga Americano kahit anong tono ang kanta walang problema pero tayo masyadong plastic na!tigilan na ninyo ang katarantadohan ninyo dahil nakakahiya ang ginagawa ninyo,bakit yun bang nakawin ang pondo ng bayan ng mga herodes na mga namumuno sa bayan natin ay masasabi mong patriotic, nagaaksaya lang kayo ng oras,ano ba ang function ng Agency nio bukod sa mangulangot,nakakahiya kayo mga SUPOT!
Hitting high notes does not make one a singer!!
Most aspiring Pinoy singers think that by being able to hit ear-piercing high notes makes a good singer. Let me tell you this; legendary singers such as Frank Sinatra, Elvis Presley, Perry Como, Tony Bennet, Julie Andrews, Barbra Streisand, to name a few made hits not mostly due to being able to hit ear-piercing high notes but due to their inherent voice quality, depth, phrasing, breathing and timing.
If you don't believe me, listen to the immortal songs like "Love Me Tender" of Elvis Presley, "it's Imposssible" of Perry Como, "My Way" of Ol' Blue Eyes, "I left My Heart in San Francisco" by Toni Bennet.
Hardly do any of those songs have ear-piercing high notes yet have stood the test of time. Thanks also to good musical arrange like Cole Porter, Henry Mancini, Rodger and Hammersteins, Burt Bacharach etc.
Now Pinoys STOP TRYING TO BE LIKE LUCIANO PAVAROTTI, God rest his soul.
Sing within your voice range and try not to break crystal with those hig pitched ear-piercing notes.