INTERACTIVE: The prosecution's case against Chief Justice Renato Corona

Posted at 03/10/12 10:51 PM


'Should I turn over CJ's SALN?'

Enriqueta Esguerra-Vidal
Clerk of Court, Supreme Court

After much trepidation, she submitted to the impeachment court Corona’s statements of assets, liabilities and net worth (SALNs). The SALNs became the centerpiece of the prosecution’s case versus the chief magistrate.

Corona worked in Palace under FVR

Marianito Dimaandal
Malacañang Records Officer

He was asked to testify on the veracity of Corona’s Statement of Assets, Liabilities and Net worth (SALN) when he was still working in the Palace for then-President Fidel V. Ramos. His testimony was questioned since it did not have anything to do with the allegation of the prosecution.

Corona owns a condo--plus 3 parking lots--at The Bellagio

Randy Rutaquio
Registrar of Deeds, Taguig City

He was asked to testify on the Corona family’s properties in Taguig. Prosecution members earlier presented documents purporting to show the sale of a 303.5-square-meter unit with three parking slots at The Bellagio in December 2009, six months before Corona’s appointment as Chief Justice by outgoing President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo.

Corona's owns a property in La Vista, a condo in One Burgundy

Carlo Alcantara
Acting Registrar of Deeds, Quezon City

He was called to give details about Corona’s condominium unit worth P2.5 million in One Burgundy Plaza in Katipunan, and a 1,200-sqm lot in La Vista Subdivision in the name of Corona's wife, Cristina.

Corona's Marikina properties

Sedfrey Garcia
Acting Registrar of Deeds, Marikina City

He was asked to give details on the Coronas’ alleged properties in Marikina. Some of the properties were included in the list of 45 properties that the prosecution claimed were owned by the Coronas.

'Corona didn't pay right taxes'

Kim Henares
Bureau of Internal Revenue Commissioner

She found alleged discrepancies in Corona’s SALNs vis-à-vis his tax returns. Because of this, she launched a separate tax investigation against Corona.

CJ paid P6.1M for McKinley Hill property

Giovanni Ng
Finance Director, Megaworld Corp.

He said it was Corona and his wife who paid for the P6.1 million-McKinley Hill property, which was registered under the name of their daughter, Ma. Charina. Corona served as attorney for his daughter.

Coronas bought a condo at The Columns in Makati

Constante Caluya Jr.
Registrar of Deeds, Makati City

He testified on the Coronas’ acquisition of a unit in The Columns in Ayala.

Coronas own a condo at Bonifacio Ridge

Aniceto Bisnar Jr.
Vice-President, Strategic Landbank Management Corp., Ayala Land Inc.

He testified that the Coronas issued checks for the unit at the Bonifacio Ridge Condominium in Taguig. He said these were paid in 2 installment terms. He admitted not seeing if the unit was turned over to the Coronas.

'Megaworld gave CJ a 40% discount and more'

Noli Hernandez
Senior Vice-President for Marketing and Sales, Megawaorld Corp.

He testified that it was "force majeure" which prompted the company to give a 40% discount amounting to P10 million to Corona for his condominium at The Bellagio in Fort Bonifacio. His testimony backfired on the prosecution.

Basa-Guidote's registration revoked since 2003

Benito Cataran
Director, Company Registration and Monitoring Department, Securities and Exchange Commission

He said Basa-Guidote Enterprises Inc.’s certificate of registration was revoked in 2003 and has thus been dissolved as a company. BGEI is the company owned by the family of Cristina Corona. The prosecution said this puts to question the truthfulness of Corona’s SALN, which shows an P11-million cash advance from BGEI which Corona supposedly used to pay for his property purchases.

Coronas paid P3.5M for The Columns

Nerissa Josef
Assistant Vice-President, Ayala Land

She testified that the Coronas bought a 48-square-meter condominium unit in The Columns in Makati City for P3,588,931 in 2003. She said the Coronas started paying in installments in 2003 but the unit was only fully paid in 2004.

Coronas own a P3.5M condo in One Burgundy

Gregg Gregonia,
Vice-President, Burgundy Realty Corp.

He brought documents in connection with the condominium unit bought by Corona and his wife in Katipunan, Quezon City. The prosecution alleged Corona belatedly disclosed in 2003 the unit even if it was purchased in 1997. The unit is worth P3.5 million, based on the reservation agreement.

'Corona's dollar accounts are absolutely secret'

Pascual Garcia III
President, Philippine Savings Bank

He was asked to testify on Corona’s dollar accounts with PSBank. He refused, however, saying the Foreign Currency Deposit Act disallows the disclosure of foreign currency accounts. He did, however, testify on Corona's peso accounts in PSBank.

Corona had P12M in BPI in end 2010

Leonora Dizon
Branch Manager, Bank of the Philippine Islands - Ayala Branch

She said Corona's checking account with account number 1445-8030-61 had a total balance of P12,024,067.70 as of December 31, 2010. This is higher than the P3.5 million in cash and investments Corona declared in his 2010 Statement of Assets, Liabilities and Net worth (SALN).

'Prosecution's specimen card is fake'

Anabelle Tiongson
Branch Manager, PSBank - Katipunan Branch

She brought records showing that Corona had P19.7 million cash PSBank Katipunan by end-December 2010. She became controversial when the issue of a specimen card bearing Corona’s alleged dollar account was brought out by the prosecution. Senator-judge Jinggoy Estrada said Tiongson’s family was close to the family of lead prosecutor Niel Tupas. She denied, however, that the specimen card was leaked by the branch. She said the card was “fake.”

'My boss just gave birth, substitute lang ho'

Mara Arcilla
Assistant Branch Manager, BPI Ayala Ave., SGV Branch

She substituted for her boss, Leonoro Dizon, who gave birth during a scheduled testimony.

Corona's 'injustice' to FASAP

Roberto Anduiza
President, Flight Attendants' and Stewards' Association of the Philippines (FASAP)

He was a “volunteer witness” for the prosecution. He said they want Corona removed from office for intervening in the retrenchment case of the flight attendants against PAL. He alleged Corona acted on a mere letter from PAL lawyer Estelito Mendoza, leading to a reversal of an SC ruling in favor of FASAP.

'CJ tried to let GMA escape criminal prosecution'

Leila de Lima
Secretary, Department of Justice

sing the dissenting opinion of Supreme Court Associate Justice Lourdes Sereno magistrate, she said Corona may have had a hand in pushing the high court to issue a Temporary Restraining Order (TRO) on former President Gloria Macapagal Arroyo’s travel restraint issued by the Department of Justice (DOJ). Her testimony was allowed to stay on the record even after it was described as hearsay.

'GMA's illness not life-threatening'

Dr. Juliet Cervantes
GMA's attending physician, St. Luke's Medical Center

She testified on the medical condition of former President Gloria Macapagal Arroyo.

Corona worked for Arroyo when she was VP

Emma Abanador
Chief Administrative Officer, Office of the Vice-president

She said Corona worked with Arroyo when she was still the Vice President. The defense did not deny this.

'I'm just a cameraman'

Edmond Losalla
Cameraman, ABS-CBN News

He was asked to authenticate videos that revolved around the Supreme Court’s issuance of the Temporary Restrainig Order (TRO) on former President Arroyo’s travel restraint.

Corona was PGMA's chief of staff, et al

Elenita Gatbunton
Division Chief, Malacañang Records Office

She said Corona worked with Arroyo when she was still President. Corona was acting executive secretary, presidential spokesman, and presidential chief of staff in the Arroyo administration.

'I took video of GMA at the airport'

Danny Piedad
Cameraman, ABS-CBN News

He was asked to authenticate videos taken during Arroyo’s attempt to leave the country.

Subpoenaed ABS-CBN videos are authentic

Rochelle Mendez
Librarian, ABS-CBN Corp.

She was asked to authenticate videos subpoenaed from ABS-CBN.