Noynoy softens stand on RH bill
2nd in a series on ANC's Presidential Youth Forum at De La Salle University, January 29, 2010
_________________________________________________________________________________
MANILA, Philippines - Presidential candidate Senator Benigno “Noynoy” Aquino III has softened his stand on the Reproductive Health (RH) bill.
At the ABS-CBN News Channel's Presidential Youth Forum at De La Salle University (DLSU) on Friday, Aquino said he still wants Filipinos to be educated on the various methods of family planning and be free to choose which method they prefer.
However, instead of his strong categorical statements in favor of making contraceptives available in all government hospitals, Aquino said he now believes the pending RH bill must be amended.
“There are provisions that I cannot support,” Aquino said. “I was mistakenly labeled as co-author [of the bill]. Actually, I’m listed as interpellator, and I’m waiting for my opportunity."
“But having said that, I still think that this is a problem that we cannot bury our heads in the sand. Kailangan natin tugunan. Habang hindi inaasikaso ang problema, tuloy lalaki ang problem at tuloy ang pasakit sa taongbayan,” he added.
The pro-artificial contraception policy in the RH bill has inspired its advocates but ruffled the feathers of the Catholic church.
'Responsible Parenthood'
Aquino has chosen to use the more careful term “responsible parenthood” in explaining his policy on family planning.
“I think that we will all agree that if you look at one parameter—for instance, education—there is a dearth of classrooms anywhere from 20,000 to 40,000. We are not already able to meet the needs of the people who are already here."
"Responsible parenthood basically says each parent should be reminded, 'May dinala kayong anak sa mundong ito. Meron kayong obligasyon na sila’y paaralin, pakainin, patirahin ng maayos, damitan, at iba pa.' Ano ang solusyon dyan? Meron po tayong educational campaign na ipapatupad,” Aquino said.
In contrast, Senator Manuel Villar--who is second to Aquino in the latest presidential surveys--has always been against the reproductive health bill.
During Friday's debate, he said a well-managed economy would be able to provide a big population “the kind of life that they want.”
“Huwag natin gawing batas. Dapat ang pamahalaan ang mag-ayos ng ekonomiya,” he said.
Deliberations on the RH bill have been stalled in Congress. Villar said there’s no more time to pass it in the 14th Congress.
There are only 3 remaining session days left before Congress adjourns on February 5 for the election campaign.
Aquino used to be all-out for RH bill
Last year, Aquino gave much stronger statements in support of the RH bill.
In sorties and media interviews, he had declared that he wants contraceptives to be available in government health centers.
He said couples should be free to choose the family planning method they prefer based on their conscience and beliefs. He said the Catholic Church, which opposes the use of contraceptives, should not intervene in this government program.
Supporters of the RH bill had latched on to Aquino’s popularity to push public support for the bill.
But Aquino’s stand, which contradicts the position of his late mother President Corazon Aquino, ruffled the feathers of the Catholic Church. It led a number of bishops to speak against Aquino. (Read story: Cebu archbishop dismayed with Noynoy)
It seemed then that Aquino was unaffected by these criticisms from the Catholic Church.
“I don’t care if the Catholic Church will abandon me because of my support for the ‘reproductive health’ bill. I cannot allow a church-run state. The church teaches me that I will follow my conscience. My conscience tells me that we have an overpopulation problem. I have to address it; we need to control the population. We must ensure full availability of contraceptives,” according to an October 2009 www.inquirer.net story quoting Aquino.
Compromise on contractualization
Asked on his stand on labor contractualization, Aquino said the best solution is to find a middle ground between the interests of workers and business owners.
“Gusto kong sugpuin. But at the same time, ayoko namang patayin ang mga negosyong kakaunti na lang nga pong nandyan. Walang makikitang solusyon sa extreme position. Saan ba ang happy compromise dito na tutugunan ang kapakanan ng manggagawa at natutugunan ang pangangailangan ng negosyo para maka-compete sa global market,” Aquino said in Friday's debate.
He said the ideal solution is to upgrade the skills of the workers.
“Our platform stresses education. Education enhances the skills. Job potentials open up because of an enhanced and more skillful labor force. It will hopefully ensure the tenure and potential for meaningful and dignified jobs,” he said.
Closure on GMA controversies
As in previous presidential debates, Aquino reiterated that he will seek “closure” on controversies hounding President Arroyo.
“There should be closure on all of the issues. Kailangan may resolution. Kung sino ang may kasalanan, kailangan may panagutan,” he said.
Asked what he will prioritize, Aquino said, “Mahaba listahan. She has destroyed a lot of institutions. Pati ang simbahan nakwe-question. Ang dating mali, nagiging sistema na."
What overpopulation?
Proponents of H.B, 5043 "Reproductive Health" bill always cite that that the Philippines is over-populated at 90+ million people to rationalize their support for artificial birth control. But is the country really overpopulated? And the implication is that our country is poor because of that 90+ million figure.
Population figures are meaningless if we don't take into consideration the area where that figure lives. For example, what does it mean that Japan has 128 million people? Or that the U.S.A. has 300 million?
Let's take a look at a sample of Wikipedia's listing of countries according to population DENSITY, or the number of people in every square kilometer (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_and_dependencies_by_popul...), Fegruary 7, 2010:
Rank -- Country -- People/Sq.Km.
1 -- Macau -- 18,534
2 -- Monaco -- 16,923
3 -- Singapore -- 7,022
4 -- Hong Kong -- 6,348
=====
43 -- Philippines -- 307
=====
129 -- Ethiopia -- 71
Compared to the thousands of the top 4 most-densely populated countries, the Philippines at 307 is hardly "over-populated".
And what about the overpopulation=poverty myth? The top 4 countries are so RICH! Macau is Asia's playground for billionaires, streets choked with Rolls Royces. Monaco is summer capital to Europe's kings, princes, dukes and other royalty. No need to say anything about Singapore and Hong Kong.
These top 4 countries are so small and have no natural resources to brag about but yet so rich. So is the Philippines poor because there are "too many" Filipinos and that we have no natural resources? Look at Ethiopia in Africa. If less people means more wealth to be shared, Ethiopia should be at the top of the list, instead of being one of the world's poorest.
Some people may argue that the top 4 are rich because they are small and easy to manage in spite their large population. So let's look at huge China with its 1.3 BILLION. It is the fastest growing economy in the world, predicted to overtake the U.S.A. very soon, and even now lends money to the U.S.A.!
Right within our own country, compare the population-to-wealth ratio of Sequijor, Cebu and Manila. Obviously, the more population, the better off the place.
Now guess what is our country's biggest dollar earner? It's our Overseas Foreign Workers - human life.
Clearly, life is God's GIFT and a nation's WEALTH!
So what is causing our poverty?
RIIIGHT! CORRUPTION! And the guilty ones hide their sins by blaming us the people for having too many children! What if by a miracle, our population is cut in half a year from now, will our country start getting richer if corruption is still there?
Hmmm...
NYAHAHAHAHA!
ANONG RH BILL??? ITIGIL NA YANG KALOKOHANG YAN! EH PAANO KUNG GUSTO NAMIN MAMBUNTIS??? MASARAP YATA YUN NYAHAHAHAHA!
BUTASIN ANG CONDOM! YAN ANG PARAAN PARA MAKABUNTIS! NYAHAHAHA!
Catholic church threat
The Catholic church is deceiving us in presenting the RH Bill as pro-abortion.Then they sort of blackmail the politicians who are against their stand on this issue come election day.Hanggang kailan kayo makikialam sa gobyerno?
WOW!
walang isang salita! at wlang prinsipyo! gangyan kyo dalawa ni mar.
sa infomercial ni mar na bike sa na dw! sabay pasa kay noy! tsk tsk
Noynoy's waterloo
Dito matatalo si Noynoy. Walang isang salita. Dati matigas ang suporta niya sa RH bill, ngayon lumambot na. Natakot ba siya sa banta ng simbahan na hindi siya susuportahan? Eh ano! Ang bayan naman at hindi simbahan ang dapat masunod. Hindi pwedeng ganito ang lider, kailangan matatag sa paninindigan. Kung kapakanan ng bayan ang nasa likod ng kanyang paniniwala, hindi dapat ipagsaalang-alang ang dikta ng simbahan, lalo na't makasasama sa bayan. Ang interes ng bayan ay hindi kakambal ng interes ng simbahan. Ang problema ni Noynoy, gusto niyang pagtamain o kaya magpareho. Hindi pwede. Magkaiba at darating ang oras magkakahiwalay ng landas. Ang suporta dapat sa RH bill, "all or nothing", hindi bakla, tulad ng iniisip ni Noynoy. Sino sa akala niya ang hindi magiisip na natakot siguro siya sa simbahan. Kung sa isang panukala pa lang atras na agad siya, asahan mo't sa pagiging presidente niya, mga pari ang magpapatakbo ng gobierno, at ang interes ng simbahan ang mangingibabaw, hindi ang interes ng bayang Pilipino. At balik tayo uli daang taong nakaraan nang ang mga paring katoliko ang hari.
Blunder After Blunder
Not too long ago, Noynoy threatened the Supreme Court, a co-equal branch of the Executive branch, "If I get elected as president, I won't recognize the Chief Justice, if Arroyo appointed him". Blunder after blunder. Noynoy should follow his nature and stop listening to the people behind him. He should should stop thinking that he will win the election by running a campaign against the Arroyos, you are not running against GMA. In case you have not notice yet, you are running against Villar, and he is fast catching up with you. Hate is not the nature of your persona because the people thinks of you as the honest, pure and simple man. Be yourself for Ninoy & Cory's names sake!
"I Cannot Allow A Church-Run-State"
What happened to Noynoy's statement "I cannot allow a church-run-state" when he was still standing strong in favor of the RH Bill? I'm telling you, the people behind Noynoy's candidacy is just going to make a clown out of this clueless son of Ninoy & Cory. The Black & White movement and Drilon is going to destroy his credibility and tarnish the Aquino (Hero and Saint) name. I pray that Noynoy realize, sooner than later, that there's prize of using his dad and mom's name into the current political game. The problem is, he doesn't have the "Ninoy Smart" in him, nor his sister "Kris". May their parent's soul rest in peace!!!
Bata batuta
tsk..tsk..tsk..yung mga tikasin pwede ba tigilan nyo na ang mag produce ng anak kung hindi ninyo kayang panagutan at sa mga kababaihan naman nawala na ba talaga ang pagiging pino o pagka mahinhin ninyo, konting boladas lang ng mga lalake bigay kaagad kayo...konting pino.
RH BILL IPASA!
Isa sa malaking problema ng bansa ay yung populasyon. Napakaliit ng ekonomiya natin para ma-sustain ang napakaraming tao. Ang masakit, walang patid ang paggawa ng bata lalo na sa mga squatter's area. May kapitbahay ako na 10 ang anak sa unang asawa pa lang! Ngayon, palaboy-laboy sa kalye yung mga anak.
mga commenters, stay on the topic please. RH Bill pinag uusapan dito.
Dyos ko po!
Dyos ko po parang awa nyo na wag nyo iboto tong si Noynoy kung may awa kayo kay Juan dela Cruz eto Profile nya:
http://www.abs-cbnnews.com/research/09/09/09/biodata-benigno-noynoy-aqui...
Sa loob ng 6 years sa congress at 3 years sa senate 5 house bill at 2 house resolution lang ang nagawa. Nangangahulugan na napakatamad nya hindi sya productive nakakaawa naman tayong mga tax payers magluluklok tayo ng Presidenteng walang ginagawa..
Please lang mag isip isip kayo!!