'Wrong data in CF cards may cause PCOS reading errors'
MANILA, Philippines - An IT consultant on Tuesday said wrong configurations of the compact flash cards in the precinct count optical scan (PCOS) machines may have caused glitches in reading votes for the local races.
IT expert Lito Averia of AES Watch said the failure of PCOS machines to read votes for local positions during mock PCOS tests in various municipalities could be traced to the design of the ballots. Averia said the Commission on Elections decided to change the listing of the names on the ballots from a vertical list to a horizontal list.
Averia said the PCOS machines are configured to read which ovals are shaded on the ballot based on the "intersections of the longitude and latitude of the ballot."
"The machine will expect to check if the ovals are shaded. I think that set of data was not properly configured or properly prepared. The machines read the ballots in 2 phases, the national and local. When the machines read the local, I think it got lost somewhere. It's not the configuration of the machine. The machine is somewhat confused because you're giving it the wrong directions. It is looking here when it should be looking somewhere else," he told ANC's Dateline Philippines.
Averia said the wrong configurations affected only the local positions and did not seem to affect the national positions.
An abs-cbnNEWS.com/Newsbreak report on Monday said vote counting machines in at least 4 localities failed to correctly read the ballots and tally the votes during mock polls, affecting local positions and raising concerns that a scenario is being created by some quarters to revert the conduct of the polls to the manual system. (Read: Local bets get zero votes as PCOS machines malfunction)
Some candidates for local positions in Pasay City; Makati City; Sto. Tomas, Batangas; and Mamburao, Occidental Mindoro got zero votes despite the fact that their poll watchers accomplished the ballots, and should assure them of as many votes in the results.
The malfunctioning of the precinct count optical scan (PCOS) machines spared no political parties and didn't appear to target particular positions.
The malfunctions prompted Comelec to postpone all further testing and sealing of the PCOS machines throughout Luzon (including the National Capital Region), Visayas and Mindanao to May 7. (Read: Errors force Comelec to reset PCOS testing)
Averia said Smartmatic-TIM has to recall all compact flash cards that have been deployed and reconfigure them to read votes for the local races in all 1,630 municipalities and districts in the country.
"They have to prepare the proper data for each ballot configuration. The Comelec has 1,630+ ballot configurations corresponding to the number of municipalities and districts. They have to prepare the correct data and put that into the flash cards. That is easy to do. The biggest challenge is logistical, recalling all those compact flash cards that were deployed, bringing them back to Smartmatic for reconfiguration and then delivering them back to the polling precincts. That would be the major challenge."
Averia said the cards have to be in proper containers, not exposed to water, dust or magnetic fields. "Dust particles can get into the contact points. Smartmatic is using industrial grade flash cards, unlike the consumer grade," he said.
He added that IT professionals had earlier proposed a parallel manual count because there was not enough time to prepare for the electoral exercise.
Only Parallel Count or Manual Count can save this Election
They are not super man... how sure that the issues only in the local? kasi may mga reports din sa national level.. pero mas malaki ung sa local.. so nakikita na natin na unti unti ng napuzzle ung ginawa ni Arroyo... midnight appoinments... plan A was Villaroyo pero nalalamangan na ni Erap... so next is PCOS machine.. wahahahahhaha... parang if this election will not happen the president will retain its power.. tsk tsk tsk... hndi na ito malayong mangyari only 6days pero on recall pa lang ang mga cards.. hindi naman sila cguro c Superman para ma resolve ito in an instant at hindi ma test uli? tsk tsk... im afraid walng election na magaganap not unless kung mag mano manong bilangan.. its our only hope to continue this elction... grabe....
Automation WIll Fail
Too many issues. Too many problems.
Automation poll is designed to fail.
Maraming boto ang hindi masasama. Maraming botante na ang boto ay hindi masasama. Maraming machine ang magkakaproblema sa transmission. Maraming machine ang magkaka-problema sa CF cards. Maraming CF cards ang madadaya o mawawala.
Automation poll will become a multi-billion peso failure.
And who will benefit from this failure?
No one except the incumbent administration.
It will be one big chaotic event this May 10.
Too Late for a Plan B
With Days up to the election, a plan B is useless.
I see two reasons why manual counting would not help:
1. It defeats the purpose of why we have automated the election
2. It induces chaos because now we have two results. We can't really be sure now which one is true. We just can't afford another people power. Too much is too much.
This is a large system, and unfortunately, we have awarded the project to a small-time company that needs to put-up a system that takes years to mature.
And now we are cramming on the testing phase of the project. In my school days, crammers are usually those that fail in an exam.
SOBRANG PAGMAMADALI KASI
ITO ANG NAPALA SA SOBRANG PAGMAMADALI DAHIL HINDI GINAWA ANG DAPAT GAWIN NOON MAHABA PA AT MALAYO PA ANG ELEKSYON. SABAGAY MUKHANG SINADYA LAHAT ANG MGA PANGYAYARI PARA MAKAPANDAYA NG MADALI.
Sign of Election Failure
Data in CF cards can be manipulated and that includes preferred candidates already had "votes" stored in it.
This is going to be one big mess.
It is encourage COMELEC initiate a parallel manual vote to deter cheating or data manipulation.
Just like in ATM. If we withdraw 500 pesos in ATM, the machine will give us 500 pesos but we still prefer to count it before we leave just to ensure we have the right amount in our hands.