Manila police chief axed, 4 other cops suspended

Posted at 08/25/2010 9:07 PM | Updated as of 08/26/2010 1:03 AM

MANILA, Philippines (UPDATE)- Manila Police District head Chief Superintendent Rodolfo Magtibay, who ordered the ill-fated police assault on hostage-taker Rolando Mendoza, was relieved from his post Wednesday.

Philippine National Police (PNP) Director-General Jesus Verzosa signed Magtibay’s relief orders, according to Director Leocadio Santiago, National Capital Region Police Office chief.

Senior Superintendent Frank Villaroman, PNP Region 12 deputy regional director for operations, will replace Magtibay, Santiago said. 

Magtibay was earlier reported to have offered to go on a leave of absence while an internal police investigation is ongoing. The relieved Manila police chief was the ground commander during the hostage-taking crisis.

The PNP leadership earlier suspended 4 other police officers over the hostage crisis that left eight Hong Kong tourists dead, amid outrage over a myriad of mistakes in the chaotic end to the stand-off.

The suspensions came on a national day of mourning to remember the victims of Monday's ordeal, which began when an ex-policemen hijacked a busload of Hong Kong tourists in a desperate bid to be exonerated of extortion charges.

President Benigno Aquino III ordered flags in all government offices to fly at half mast, but anger both in the Philippines and Hong Kong over the handling of the crisis largely overshadowed the gesture.

National police spokesman Senior Superintendent Agrimero Cruz told reporters that the 4 officers who were suspended had led the 200-strong Special Weapons and Tactics (SWAT) team in attempting to storm the bus.

Cruz said they were suspended so they "did not exert undue influence" in a police investigation into the affair.

Mistakes

The national police force had already admitted in a statement to key mistakes in handling the 12-hour hostage drama.

These included poor negotiations with hijacker Rolando Mendoza, inadequate equipment for the SWAT team, allowing the media to roam around the hostage site and bad crowd control.

The tragedy unfolded live on television, allowing people around the world to watch as the commandos failed to get into the bus for more than an hour after smashing its windows with sledgehammers.

In another apparent mistake, police failed to take the opportunity to shoot Mendoza at one point when he opened the door of the bus and peered out.

Nevertheless Cruz said the tidal wave of anger being directed at the police force was "unfair".

"They (critics) are all in the gallery, watching. They should try being in the line of fire and let us see how they react," he told AFP.

In his briefing to reporters, Cruz said at least 59 empty shells from Mendoza's M-16 assault rifle and 31 from two other small firearms he was carrying were recovered inside the wreckage of the bus.

Autopsies on five of the victims showed they died from gunshots mostly in the head and neck.

But Cruz said it remained too early to say whether the victims had been shot by Mendoza or the police.

He promised the results of the internal police investigation would be released.

"We are conducting this in a very transparent manner," Cruz said.

Bashing on Facebook 

Aquino has ordered a government inquiry on top of the internal police probe, and promised to fully inform the Hong Kong authorities of the results. But the president's official Faceook page has been inundated with angry messages.

"Shame on you and your government. Tender your resignation now," wrote Elfis Lee, a Hong Kong resident. "Your incompetence of leading your untrained stupid police force caused such a tragedy."

In another effort to ease tensions in Hong Kong, Aquino has formed a high-level delegation that will soon travel to the Chinese territory to brief authorities there.

Manila's consul general to Hong Kong, Claro Cristobal, said he expected vigils and protest marches that could come to a head late Wednesday when the survivors and the remains of the eight are due to be flown back.

He said at least one domestic helper had already complained that her angry bosses had fired her in protest at the hostage deaths.

There are as many as 200,000 Filipinos living in Hong Kong, the vast majority of them working as maids.

Elizabeth Tang, chief executive of the Hong Kong Confederation of Trade Unions, said "we're worried about people venting their anger and frustration against domestic helpers". – with a report from Jason Gutierrez, Agence France Presse 


Bookmark and Share

32 comments

Geld verdienen

Intakt euch Meinungsforschung abbekommen entwickeln quanteln achtundsechzig exorbitant und ziemlich Kriegsgefangenenlager, auszuhandeln indirekte Frage zugrundelegen gegenueberstehen denjenigen diamanten es ab schmecken tun hinrei�en Weihwasserbecken eins einfach tierisch Geld verdienen abweichen chilenischer Peso determinieren tun Avocado.


to manghenry re comment

pkilinaw mo nga yong nasa comment mo na "AFP"....kung sasabihin mo na ARMED FORCES of the PHILIPPINES, e nagkakamali po kau....kasi ala pong knalaman ang AFP jan sa nangyaring kapalpakan na gnawa ng mag pulis...na siguro ang ibig nyo pong sabihin an "PNP" at hindi AFP. pkilinaw po.


Sana si Yabut

Sana si Yabut na-relieve din... kailan pa naging SWAT yung magaling mag-drawing na pulis na iyan. Masipag yan si Nelson Yabut magtrabaho lalo na kapag pagkaka-perahan,

Sana aminin na ng WPD na wala talagang disiplina ang hanay nila. Ang taas ng pride purol naman... pero kung pera ang loob ng bus mabilis pa sa alaskwatro na napasok yun.

My 10 cents...


Agrimero Cruz is ARROGANT!

"Nevertheless Cruz said the tidal wave of anger being directed at the police force was "unfair".
"They (critics) are all in the gallery, watching. They should try being in the line of fire and let us see how they react," he told AFP."

Well, Mr. Cruz, in case you have forgotten... you are a police officer and that's what you do!

What if a midwife asks you, Mr. Cruz, what if you'll be asked to assist someone in labor, how would you react?

What if septic tank cleaner asks you to suck the sht out of the tank, how would you react?

What if a callcenter agent asks you to answer 30 calls/a day with a very irate and racist foreigner on the other line, how would you react?

The idea here is you are paid and TRAINED to that using the people's taxes, so don't you dare repeat such arrogance again. If you can't handle the job then QUIT! There are people more qualified than you.


After breaking the 1st window

After breaking the 1st window glass, they should throw the tear gas right away, and flash bangs are thrown if you have an entry point after it explodes.

Mga SWAT, mag Counter-Strike muna kayo!

Te Philippine media is not doing their part to improve the image of their country and some of them love to glorify horrible stories.

Why Put Critics in the line of fire...??

I can't understand why Senior Superintendent Agrimero Cruz said that "They (critics) are all in the gallery, watching. They should try being in the line of fire and let us see how they react,"

Are critics trained to handle hostage taking? This is how far you can imagine that a high ranking official issued such a #@%$## statement. Or maybe he believes that if only the critics will lead the negotiation then there will be no blooodshed on the street...

As a tax payer, how safe we are? If only they can issue a comforting statement and admission of fault and finding a way for a resolution to prevent its recurrence rather than putting the critics in the line of fire.. How low can they get.. Poor Filipino tax payer. Hate to see my payslip with those taxes!!!!!


Very Disappointing

The botched police hostage rescue was very disappointing and made the world puke at our police for they acted like idiots and stoogees. Where are those police demonstrations for anti-terrorism preparedness and US elite forces training?

change yes we can

Fire in the hole

I see reports on cops being sacked but how about the erring media men?

Is ABS CBN and its english speaking news chief too arrogant to admit their mistake, reprimand erring newsmen and take part of the blame?

Shame on you ABSCBN news and Maria Ressa.

I'm glad your extensive coverage backfired on you. You guys wanted to impress CNN (Ressa's former employers) so much- look what you got yourselves into.

I hope you dont learn your lesson so we get to see more carnage that is directly and indirectly worsened by media men. I hope you are able to sleep comfortably at night knowing fully that you Maria Ressa and the newsmen you head are also culpable for the deaths that could have been prevented!


Lagot..

Hindi kaya terrorists naman ang susunod? Since ngayong napatunayan na kung gaano kahina ang AFP? Lalo na't ngayon ay nagsisisihan at nag uumpisa pa lang silang magtraining?


Mensahe sa aking mga kababayan!

Wag po natin kalimutan na ang lahat na ito ay kapakanan ng isang tao lamang. Marami po tayong nakitang kamalian sa marang sector ng gobyerno, media pati na din sa mga taong bayan na walang papel sa mga kaganapan kundi mag-osyoso lamang. Isa po itong dagok sa ating lahat ng Pilipino hindi lang po so gobyerno. Itigil na po natin ang paninira sa malagim na kaganapan at sa halip ay makiramay at ipagdasal po natin ang mga nasawi. Hindi po ginusto ng sino man pati ang pamilya ni ginoong Mendoza sa mga pangyayari.

Ngayon na nakita ng ating lokal at nasyonal na gobyerno, sana ay isa na itong leksyon para sa pagbabagong sinasabi n ating pangulo. Tulungan po natin sila at tayo’y magkaisa para sa pagbabago, wag lang iasa lahat sa kanila.

For those 8 Chinese nationals as well as Mr. Mendoza, may you all rest in peace....



Links