Gov't hit over aid delay after storm kills 140

Posted at 09/28/2009 9:13 PM | Updated as of 09/28/2009 9:13 PM

MANILA - Philippine officials scampered to send relief aid on Monday to hundreds of thousands hit by weekend floods in and around Manila, while anger mounted over what was seen as an inadequate response from the government.

As the death toll from flash floods soared to 140, analysts said the anger could damage the prospects of Defense Secretary Gilberto Teodoro, the administration's candidate in the May 2010 presidential election.

"His 0.2 percent popularity could be zero by now," said political analyst and columnist Nelson Navarro, of Teodoro.

President Gloria Macapagal Arroyo, already deeply unpopular in opinion polls, ordered an emergency center be set up in the presidential palace on Monday, two days after the floods, highlighting for some the haphazard response to the disaster.

At least 450,000 people were affected, including about 150,000 displaced.

Officials said the economic damage from the worst rains on record in the Manila area was about P1.4 billion ($30 million), including P500 million in lost crops. Damaged roads and bridges accounted for most of the remaining costs.

Officials expected the toll to rise with people looking for missing relatives and residents trapped in flooded houses two days after Typhoon Ketsana dumped about 410 mm of rain in 24 hours, about the average amount of rainfall for an entire month.

'Once-in-a-lifetime typhoon'

Mrs. Arroyo called the typhoon "an extreme event that has strained our response capabilities to the limit. But it is not breaking us." "It's a once-in-a-lifetime typhoon," she said in a statement. "We are continuing the rescue efforts until everyone in danger is accounted for."

While waters had receded from most flooded areas in Manila, some parts of the city of 15 million remained cut off and in others, mud and garbage was left caked on streets.

Schools were ordered closed, but financial markets were open on Monday and public transport was operating. Offices and businesses were open, but attendance was poor.

"There was a massive failure in government and the direction of management response," said Mario Taguiwalo, president of the National Institute for Policy Studies think-tank.

"The root cause is you have a government whose predominant preoccupation is with graft and corruption -- how to steal more money from the people," Taguiwalo said.

"If your officials are not motivated to serve and just motivated to steal, then that's the kind of response you get."

'Too little, too late'

For many the disaster revealed the divisions that separate the city's rich and poor, and problems with planning and development in the city.

"Why is it that rich villages get help first?" said Bobby Santillosa, head of a neighborhood-based disaster-response team in Bagong Silangan, a low-income northern Manila neighbourhood.

The community leader saw 29 neighbors drown in the flooding sparked by tropical storm Ketsana, when more than a month of rain fell in less than nine hours.

"They were already dead when rescuers arrived," he added.

Bayani Fernando, the Metropolitan Manila Development Authority chief who is responsible for flood control in the capital, said that among the major factors in the flood were poor city planning, illegal structures and simple geography.

"Our problem is we live where we should never have lived," he said.

Manila, which like most of the country lies on the Pacific typhoon belt, is bisected by the Pasig and Marikina rivers whose waters connect Manila Bay to the west with a huge lake, Laguna de Bay, to the east.

Some areas of the city lie below sea level, sit on silt and rely on pumps to keep the water out, while the eastern district of Marikina, ground zero of the disaster, is a valley surrounded by the Sierra Madre mountain range.

He said obstructions, either caused by squatters putting up illegal structures or rich landowners encroaching on land such as riverbanks that allow natural drainage, should be removed.

"If we want to stop this, we have to remove all the things that are obstructing the waters," Fernando said. With reports from Reuters and Agence France-Presse

 


Bookmark and Share

4 comments

NO MORE CALAMITY FUND

ARROYO SPENT EVERYTHING FOR HER TOUR ABROAD...BUT MIND YOU ..THE GOVT GOT PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION FUND FOR GIBO....ALL FOR ADVERTISING ..WHAT A COUNTRY OF CORRUPT GOVERNMENT SECRETARIES ..ALL FOR THE PRESS REALEASE PROGRAMS OF GOVERNMENT MISMANAGERS...NO MORE 800 MILLION PESOS CALAMITY FUND ... NASA BULSA NA NILA LAHAT


Failed Response

The government failed response to the victims caused more deaths.

It is not just about there are too much rain. It is about the failure of our government's ability to response to situation such as this. NDCC and the national government, even the LGUs will make excuses but they cannot escape tha fact that internet, from facebook to twitter, is already flooded with calls for help and none of them did anything to save them. These people endured hours of fear and desperation before they receive help. In fact, they got help from neighbors, relatives and friends. And the death could have been minimize if only the government was there to provide assistance.

NDCC is headed by Gibo who is busy trying to WIN the presidential election this 2010.


'Once-in-a-lifetime typhoon'

Dapat PANDAK sa PAGASA ka nagtrabaho hindi sa Malacanang...ano pinagsasabi no once in a lifetime, nakailan bagyo na ako sa buhay ko ah...."Gov't hit over aid delay" lumang tugtugin na ito, basta pag dumating ang unos motto ninyo search and rescue at pag wala na kayong magagawa kundi nag tumunganaga isip na lang ng lusot wala man lang kayong maisip na solusyon bago dumating mga problema puro kasi kickback at nakaw dito nakaw doon ang alam ninyo...ay naku dapat mga pinoy mag invest ng kanya kanyang rubber boat at life jacket dahil hindi lang pala sa sulpicio nagyayrai ito pati sa napakagandang administrasyon ni Shorty. dapat sa inyo pati na si GIBS at BAYANI paguuntugin mga ulo ninyo...kawawang pinoy di na ata makakakita ng pagasa sa sariling bayan

o eto tignan mo magaling mo anak ano pinaggagawa habang binabaha

http://www.facebook.com/photo.php?pid=9002085&id=660070410&ref=nf#/photo...

huwag ako tanungin mo dahil hindi ko kainuman magaling mong anak


Napalusot Pa Itong Si Pandak.

Wala po talaga tayong magagawa sa pagdating ng malakas na bagyo subali't magagawa nating paghandaan ang pagdating nito upang ang mga tao ay mabigyan ng babala at maligtas sa sakuna.

Ang tunay na problema ay hindi itong si Ondoy kundi ang NDCC na walang ginawa upang ipatupad ang Four Point Plan of Action for Preparedness (4PPAP) na isinasaad sa Presidential Directive 1566.

Yun lang pag babala sa mga tao na lumikas dun sa mga vulnerable areas tulad ng Cainta at Marikina BAGO PA DUMATING SI ONDOY ay hindi pa nagawa.

Yun lang pagbili at paggamit ng Doppler Radar upang malaman ang dami ng tubig na dala ni Ondoy ay hindi pa nagawa.

Tapos may gana pang gumawa ng dahilan itong nasa puwesto, nasalanta na at namatay na ang mga tao, lolokin pa nila?

Ang four point plan na ito ay ang mga sumusunod:

• Upgrading of the Philippine Atmospheric, Geo-physical and Astronomical Services Administration (PAGASA) and Philippine Institute of Volcanology and Seismology (PHIVOLCS) Forecasting Capability - The capability upgrade focused on improving forecasting capability of natural hazards such as typhoons, earthquakes, volcanic eruptions and tsunamis through the acquisition of
equipment and personnel development. The capability upgrade is geared
towards strengthening linkages with foreign forecasting institutions to make forecasting, not only a domestic, but a regional concern. Geo-hazard mapping in identified areas is designed to serve as scientific reference for land-use planning, formulation of disaster management plans, and establishment of an effective early warning system to include real-time information dissemination.

• Public Information Campaign on Disaster Preparedness - Development and implementation of a strategic communications plan to increase awareness of the public on natural hazards and communicate effectively preparedness measures that can be undertaken by the community in case these hazards translate into emergencies.

• Capacity Building for Local Government Units in Identified Vulnerable Areas - Provide technical assistance to local government units of identified vulnerable communities in formulating and developing programs particularly in the area of mitigation and preparedness.

• Mechanisms for Government and Private Sector Partnership in Relief and Rehabilitation - To come up with a mechanism that will promote government and private sector-community participation synergy, and improve coordination to achieve a seamless interface of local and national interventions through effective logistics management, information management and redundant communications systems.



Links