PAGASA sought high-tech radars 5 years and 54 typhoons ago

Posted at 10/02/2009 6:52 PM | Updated as of 10/03/2009 9:03 PM

Doppler radar that could have predicted volume of Ondoy’s rainwater to come in December yet

MANILA - If Doppler radars were in place before a rain-heavy typhoon like Ondoy hit Luzon last weekend, the fatalities could not have reached 280, and the damages on infrastructure and agriculture almost P5 billion, critics of the weather bureau are saying.

The Philippine Atmospheric, Geophysical and Astronomical Services Administration (PAGASA) has been saying that, too—for the last 5 years.

The Doppler is an instrument that can monitor the intensity and volume of rainfall, and could have warned the country’s meteorologists and authorities that Ondoy would be dumping a month’s worth of rain in just 6 hours. Precautions could have been taken, and early evacuation conducted.

Yet in a country that experiences an average of 20 tropical depressions, storms, and typhoons a year, the first brand new Doppler radar will be installed by December yet—5 years after PAGASA requested for it, and about 20 years after other countries first used such instrument for weather forecasting.

PAGASA Director Prisco Nilo told Newsbreak that, with a Doppler radar, his agency could have issued flood bulletins that would identify flood-prone areas, since their equipment can already gauge the volume of water that may pour into areas like Metro Manila.

Typhoon Ondoy left 80 percent of Metro Manila—especially the cities of Marikina, Manila, and Pasig—under water. The municipalities of Cainta, San Mateo, Angono, and Tanay in Rizal province were submerged. The floods displaced more than 400,000 people, and killed 280 people.

Limited predictions
Nilo admitted that the current weather monitoring system on which Metro Manila depends is not capable of calculating the rate of rainfall in millimeter per hour. And it’s located in Baler, Aurora, some 100 kilometers from Manila.

At present, warning signals for the Metro Manila area come from a weather satellite receiving system in Baler. The system is limited to making “indicative predictions,” like figuring the gustiness of the wind, the strength of the rain, and cloudiness.

PAGASA began using weather satellites in the 1980s, and has been regularly upgrading them when new technology becomes available. Recently, it spent around P5 million for the system’s enhancement.

“We don’t have a radar right now covering Metro Manila. The nearest radar is located in Baler, Aurora, which cannot reach us. We are looking into issuing flood bulletins every now and then when the Doppler radar is already installed,” Nilo explained, following the statement of Albay Governor Joey Salceda that the disaster could have been mitigated had PAGASA also issued flood warnings.

There are currently 5 operational radars located in Aparri in Cagayan, Baguio City, Baler in Aurora, Virac in Catanduanes, and Guiuan in Eastern Samar.

The old radar in Baler was recently upgraded into Doppler. However, this radar can only monitor the provinces in Northern and Central Luzon.

P100 million each
Nilo said the Doppler radar, a brand new one, that can monitor the areas of Metro Manila, Batangas, and Laguna, is expected to be installed in Subic in Zambales before the year ends.

PAGASA is procuring 5 brand new Doppler radars. Each radar will entail a cost of P100 million, to include the construction of the facility that will house the radar and the access road to the facility.

The funds for 3 Dopplers came from the President’s calamity fund, and those for 2 more came from the Department of Science and Technology.

The 5 Dopplers will be installed in Subic, Tagaytay City, Mactan City, Surigao del Sur, and Tampakan in South Cotabato.

PAGASA is also discussing with the Japan International Cooperation Agency possible funding for 3 more Doppler radars to replace the radars in Catanduanes, Cagayan, and Eastern Samar.

Doppler radars have been used for weather forecasting in developed countries like the United States since the 1980s or early 1990s. In the US, even some broadcast stations have their own Doppler radars for their weather news. Our neighboring countries—like Malaysia, Taiwan, and Thailand—adopted the new technology a few years after it was introduced.

Aurora, Quezon tragedies
Before PAGASA decided that it had to shift to Doppler radars, the Philippines had faced 5 destructive typhoons from 1990 to 1998. Typhoon Uring devastated Ormoc City in Leyte in 1991, claiming some 8,000 lives and damaged P1 billion worth of properties. After that, Super Typhoon Rosing battered Metro Manila and neighboring provinces, killing 936 people and causing P11 billion in damages to properties.

In November of 2004, heavy rains triggered flashfloods and massive landslides in the provinces of Aurora and Quezon, leaving more than 1,700 people dead and P12 billion worth of properties damaged.

The tragedy finally made PAGASA propose to the national government funding for the purchase of Doppler radars. In 2005, in fact, the National Disaster and Coordinating Council issued an action plan, which placed the improvement of PAGASA’s facilities as a top priority.

The funds didn’t come immediately, however. It was only in June 2008 that PAGASA was able to award a contract for the procurement of 5 Doppler radars. It was awarded to Enterprise Electronics Corporation, a US-based manufacturer of meteorological radars.

The agreement is for Enterprise Electronics to deliver the radars in June 2010. Nilo explained that Doppler radars are not “out of the shelf” equipment, and manufacturing takes around 18 months to finish.

PAGASA, however, requested for at least 1 unit to be installed before the year ends, considering what happened because of Typhoon Ondoy.

As PAGASA waited for the Dopplers, from 2005 to 2008, 47 typhoons hit the country. Typhoon Reming in 2006 killed more than 700 people and damaged P5.5 billion properties in Bicol. The same year, Typhoon Milenyo hit the region. More than 174 people died and P6.4 billion worth of properties were destroyed.

This year, there have 16 weather disturbances, so far. Seven of them were typhoons, including Ondoy that flooded Metro Manila and surrounding provinces, and Pepeng that threatened Northern Luzon with very strong winds.  - Newsbreak


Bookmark and Share

11 comments

No Radar on TV or Web

This news story is an important one and a long time in coming as it sheds light on an issue that has been bothering me for over a decade – that lack of weather radar coverage in the Philippines. First, let me say I am not Filipino. I am a U.S. citizen living in America, but my wife is a Filipina and we have lots of family there. I am a former TV news reporter here and very tech savvy. We watch ABS-CBN and ANC on satellite here in Virginia and also monitor many news web sites from the Philippines such as this one. We also travel to the Philippines every few years. I have been aghast at the absence of weather radar on Philippine TV and on-line. Where is it? I am not talking about the high tech Doppler radar system to which this story refers, but rather basic 50-year old weather radar technology. Why is there no weather radar shown on Philippine TV? In America, we have had weather radar on local TV for better than 35 years, with the newer Doppler systems installed at many local TV stations within the last two decades. I know PAGASA has basic weather radar systems accessible to it (I’ve seen them in the background in news reports from PAGASA), but why not also make that available to the Philippine media? Better yet, why don’t the more wealthy Philippine news channels buy and install their own such systems? If relatively small market U.S. TV stations can afford their own, why can’t ABS-CBN? Enterprise Electronics Corporation in Enterprise, Alabama, USA sells them world wide. I have no affiliation with them. Yes, Doppler is superior and can provide actual rain intensity data as well as early warning signs of tornadoes. Doppler’s absence from PAGASA is frankly scandalous. But also where is even basic weather radar on Philippine TV and web sites? Where is radar on the PAGASA web site? I only see satellite photos and drawings. I appreciate the work of meteorologists and admire their dedication, but they can do nothing without official support and funding. As an American, looking at Philippine weather forecasting is like stepping back in time. Even poor, communist Cuba has a national network of color weather radars that are accessible on-line. Filipinos, it’s time to demand accountability.

Mike Lewis, Virginia, USA


Online noise

Mr. Ausphil, we're also victims not only of calamities but of government's neglect for many years. Speaking the truth about what we’ve conceived were anomalous on the part of the state is our right being taxpayers of this nation. We’re fed up with these vicious cycle of helplessness. This is not just blaming, it’s a protest clamoring for a more efficient and caring state. We are disappointed because our taxes are not going to people’s welfare and launching our sentiments online is relevant and just.

Jo Santi

Blaming won't do any good

If you have donated to the typhoon victims fine, well done. If you don't then shut-up and start learning from this event rather than blaming your own countrymen specially those within the government. It has been 20 years of blaming and hatred towards the government what did it do? People started to build their own Philippines instead of uniting as one country. You can't say you love your country and you hate the president, you can't say you love your country and steal from your neighbor and specially you can't say you love your country and hate the system. The fact is that even though other Nation can see our potentials to be the most richest country in Asia, the weakest side of it is us. Corruption is not only about the money, it's all about morality, it's all about the environment and it's almost about everything. Where is the spirit of being the only Christian nation in Asia when hate is in each other's heart. Never the bible says hate an evil doer but hate what is evil and only by doing this I will believe that you really love our country. I don't hate you but I hate your hate campaign.


Any Warning from Baler Doppler Radar Station?

If we have one functional doppler radar at Baler to covering Central and Northern Luzon, was there an forecast or prediction made to the effect that the rain would be very heavy? It's good to ask this question from the people of these region.

PAGASA knows we lack these but wonder why place it in Baler first rather than in areas where there is heavy concentration of population, say like Metro-Manila?

Was there really one at Baler? Is it working in the first place?

Perhaps PAGASA may need to be more smarter in their forecasting, even given limited resources. Was there ever a feedback from our Baler "doppler raar" station to the impending amount of rain before it landed in Metro-Manila?

Our country is the most typhoon-prone in the world (for many centuries) and only now we are talking of doppler radars after we've lost many lives and damage to properties?

People around the world always ask this question to Filipinos: "When are you ever going to learn?


Laging ganito...

>Most typhoon-ravaged zone in the world -- NO MODERN WEATHER RADAR
>Earthquake and flood prone -- no decent rescue equipments and shoestring relief budget
>Longer coastline than the US -- no enough number of patrol boats
>Home of the world's leading rice institute IRRI -- no adequate supply of rice for local consumption
>Millions of OFW's worldwide remitting billions of pesos annually -- lacks government protection for migrant workers
>Millions living in poverty line -- government cannot provide jobs, food & adequate housing
>Lots of money switching hands during elections, impeachment & shady deals -- but no budget for pro-poor programs
>etcetera...

...because

>Lots of corrupt officials -- no government action to run after them!

Jo Santi

Hello Garci, Saka Na Muna Yang Doppler, Unahin Muna Ang Cha Cha!

Kung ang hihintayin ng mga tao ay ang pasiya ng gobyerno, talagang puputi muna ang uwak bago magkaroon ng pagbabago ang sistema natin. Kitang kita naman kung ano ang inuuna nila, hindi ang kapakanan ng bayan.


doSt - "S" Science or Sayang?

Paging DOST Alam ko marami matalino sainyo. Wish ko lang wag nyo sayangin ang talino nyo. Saan ba nanggagaling ang bagyo? Ano ba ang purpose nyo pagbili nyan? Ang bagyo madalas galing/malapit sa Samar at Catanduanes bakit sa manila nyo balak ilagay yan? Pag nangyari yan ang "S" nyo not science anymore, it will be "SAYANG". SAYANG ang utak nyo, SAYANG ang pera ng taong bayan. Higit sa lahat walang SILBI yan pag dyan nyo tinayo.


tumpak!....

korek keo dyn mga kabayang marino/emiltipa.... nag-eesep ang mga manghuhurakot sa kabang-bayan if panu cla magkaka-tongpats!.... at bka sa bubong ng palasyo ni gorya de hurakot ng bayan na nasa pampanga ilagay yang mga hi-tech equipment na yan para masagap nya agad ang mga tutang hindi tapat sa knya..... jejejejeje kaya ayaw nyang ipalagay sa catanduanes ang mga nabanggit na mga equipment gayung kinikilala ang islang de catanduanes bilang isa sa mga binabahayan ng bagyo!....

dubliner

Doppler Radar Precipitation Modes And Range

Dapat nating maintindihan kung paano gumagana ang Doppler Radar para makapagbigay tayo ng payo at kuro kuro dun sa mga maglalagay at magpapatakbo ng mga kasangkapang ito. Maraming buhay ng tao ang nakasalalay at nanganganib kung sila'y magkamali.

Unang una dapat pagisipan at pagbalakang mabuti at gumawa ng computer model o simulation ang mga eksperto natin upang matiyak na ang mga lugar na paglalagyan nitong radar ay magbibigay ng early warning at accuracy sa mga weather forecasters. Walang silbi yang radar kung laging huli ang dating ng nakukuhang data mula sa bagyong papalapit.

http://weather.noaa.gov/radar/radinfo/radinfo.html

One-hour Precipitation

This is an image of estimated one-hour precipitation accumulation on a 1.1 nm by 1 degree grid. This product is used to assess rainfall intensities for flash flood warnings, urban flood statements and special weather statements. The maximum range of this product is 124 nm (about 143 miles) from the radar location. This product will not display accumulated precipitation more distant than 124 nm, even though precipitation may be occurring at greater distances. To determine accumulated precipitation at greater distances you should link to an adjacent radar.

Storm Total Precipitation

This image is of estimated accumulated rainfall, continuously updated, since the last one-hour break in precipitation. This product is used to locate flood potential over urban or rural areas, estimate total basin runoff and provide rainfall accumulations for the duration of the event.

The maximum range of this product is 124 nm (about 143 miles) from the radar location. This product will not display accumulated precipitation more distant than 124 nm, even though precipitation may be occurring at greater distances. To determine accumulated precipitation at greater distances link to an adjacent radar.


Doppler radars

hay naku ang gobyerno nga naman ng pilipinas imagine 2005 pa ni-request, cguro naman bago mag-eleksyon ready na yang radar na yan.....

o di kaya naman wala silang mapala dyan, wala cgurong tongpats!.... hmmmmm



Links