Judge Cortez hit for lack of moral courage

Posted at 12/17/2009 7:25 PM | Updated as of 12/17/2009 7:25 PM

MANILA, Philippines - A university president is asking Quezon City Regional Trial Court Judge Luisito Cortez to resign for not having "moral courage" to take the murder case of Datu Unsay Mayor Andal Ampatuan Jr., who is suspected of leading the massacre of 57 innocent civilians in Maguindanao province last November 23.

"There is such a thing as moral courage or intellectual courage. We were taught in law school of our responsibilities, and it comes along with the dangers of the job," Lutgardo Barbo, a lawyer and president of the Philippine Normal University, told ABS-CBN's Umagang Kay Ganda.

He added: "If you have moral integrity and intellectual courage you will set that aside (threat on ones life). You do your job otherwise, look for another job and get employed elsewhere."

Barbo said Cortez "has no business to be in that position" if he refuses to handle a "dangerous" murder case. He said that instead of being fearful of his own life and his family's, Cortez should be grateful enough to have been given an opportunity "to die a meaningful death, especially for your country."

The university president added that there is no certainty that Cortez would be killed while trying the Ampatuan murder case.

Judge Antonio Eugenio, president of the Philippine Judges Association, said inhibiting from the Ampatuan murder case was Cortez's personal call.

Eugenio would not castigate Cortez but admitted that he was the first judge to refuse a case right after the raffle and without even looking at the case's records.

Without directly defending the judge, Eugenio said that there was no mention in their oath of office that judges should accept cases even if it would endanger their lives.

Barbo said Cortez's refusal to take the case might dissuade witnesses from testifying against the suspects. "Why would I talk when the judges themselves are afraid [to handle the case]," he said.

He added that Cortez's move might set a precedent and be cited by other judges to refuse cases similar to the Maguindanao mayor's murder case.

He said Cortez's decision also contributes to the "destruction not only of the institutions, but the country."

Aside from Cortez, reports said other judges in the Quezon City Regional Trial Court have expressed apprehensions in handling the case.

The judge's inhibition prompted Supreme Court Chief Justice Reynato Puno to meet with Quezon City judges on Wednesday. Puno said any judge chosen to take on the massacre case would be given full security.

The case was re-raffled on Thursday to Judge Jocelyn Solis Reyes of QCRTC Branch 221.


Bookmark and Share

7 comments

Judge Cortez

Looks like the Lady Judge got bigger balls than yours...what a shame!


judge duwag

ok lang sana kung brod mo ampatuan para mag inhibit ka, tulad ng ginawa ng isang judge na nag inhibit sa paghawak ng hazing case sa mga brods nya sa UP. pero sa kaso ng ampatuan, wala ka namang koneksyon sa mga hinayupak na yan para tanggihan mo ang kaso... pero para sa akin, mas mabuti na ang ginawa mo, kesa hawakan mo ang kaso at i-abswelto mo lang sa bandang huli

practice makes perfect, but nobody's perfect... so why practice? duh?!

SAYANG NA JUDGE

NAKAKAHIYA KA JUDGE CORTEZ HINDI KA NA DAPAT PA HUMAWAK NG KAHIT ANONG KASO DAHIL WALA NG KASIGURUHAN NA TAMA AT MAKATARUNGANANG ANG IYONG GINAGAWA… KAHIT SINONG TAO AY PUWEDE KA PAGBANTAAN AT KAHIT SINO AY KAYA KA TAKUTIN PARA LANG BUMIGAY KA SA GUSTO NILA… KUNG GANYAN ANG MENTALIDAD MO AY NAPAKA-TANGA MO SA PAGPAPAKITA MO NG TUNAY MO KULAY… DAPAT SA IYO AY SIBAKIN SA PUWESTO DAHIL SAYANG LANG ANG PERA NG TAONG BAYAN NA IPINASU-SUWELDO SA IYO...


Kotong Judge

Walang BAYAG, para kang binabae daig kapa ng mga babae Judge, tangalin mona lisensya para saan yang panDisplay sana ikahiya ka ng mga anak mo Cutex ay Cortes


Kotong Judge

Walang BAYAG, para kang binabae daig kapa ng mga babae Judge, tangalin mona lisensya para saan yang panDisplay sana ikahiya ka ng mga anak mo Cutex ay Cortes


TAGGALIN SA PWESTO

DAPAT SA MGA TAONG GANYAN TANGGALIN SA PWESTO. SO, ANG KAYANG KAYA NIYA LANG IPAKULONG AY MGA KAPWA NAMIN MAHIHIRAP.


Clean up?

It's a bit late for the clean up job on the new appointed Judge story. Her profile and story is all over the web. The least we could do is follow her lead in courage, which in return will help protect her from those cowards. In regard to FULL SECURITY, lets hope our finest wont let us down on this one. It's high time that inhumane conduct have their consequences. Let justice served then fry them SOB's!

.... "He added that Cortez's move might set a precedent and be cited by other judges to refuse cases similar to the Maguindanao mayor's murder case.

You think?

"When injustice becomes law, Resistance becomes duty!" - Thomas Jefferson


Links